| Archive for 24 Forum Chat About the Hit TV Show 24 Here! |
| DSi |
Tony Almeida alive?"At Comic Con 2007, the producers hinted that Tony Almeida may be alive. This has caused many fans to believe that Carlos Bernard will return for this season." - WikipediaSource: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/24_%28season_7%29 As I would like to see Tony come back, it would be too unrealistic, as they were so sure he was dead. What is everyone else's thoughts on this? |
|
| Terri |
I know, ive heard from several places that he was gonna return at the end of season 6 but they changed the ending at the last minute.
Ive also heard he will return in either season 7 or 8. If they can think of a VERY good reason that he is still alive i would love for him to come back, its just not the same without him. |
|
| DSi |
What would be your reasoning that he is alive? | |
| Terri |
I cant think of a reasonable explanation lol, but others have said they used Henderson stabbing him as a ploy to pretend hes dead like Jack did in 4, in order to protect Tony | |
| DSi |
Yeah, but why would Henderson be in on that plan, when he is against Tony and Jack? And what would they be protecting Tony from? | |
| Terri |
nah he wouldnt have been in on it but CTU figured that everyone though Henderson killed Tony anyway, even if Tony didnt die they made everyone think he did | |
| DSi |
I guess maybe they could have been trying to protect him from that, but Henderson wouldn't be in on it because he was the one trying to kill Tony in the first place, and he wouldn't protect him. | |
| Terri |
lol no he wasnt protecting Tony he though he killed him like everyone else | |
| DSi |
Oh, so you're saying maybe he didn't actually kill him, just put him in a coma or something? | |
| Terri |
yeah, but i dont know why he would need to fake his own death, what is he in danger from | |
| DSi |
From Henderson and Logan because they may have thought he died in the car bomb that killed Michelle. | |
| Terri |
Yeah but that was only to get Jack Back, also wouldnt Chloe have been in as much danger as Tony | |
| DSi |
Yeah, she would, so, as much as I would love to see Tony alive, I guess there really is no legitimate reason for Tony being alive. If Tony came back with an unbelievable reason, I would just be disappointed... I guess we'll just have to wait for season 7 to find out, eh? | |
| Terri |
Yeah i guess we will. | |
| DSi |
FOX marked Tony as deceased, so I don't think he is alive.
Source: http://fox.com/24/profiles/season5/ta.htm |
|
| Terri |
I know im 99% sure hes dead, but there has been so much speculation that hes returning so we just dont know lol | |
| DSi |
Yeah, that's why I think season 7 will be very interesting. | |
| Terri |
Yeah i cant believe we have to wait until January | |
| DSi |
It's too long to go without 24... | |
| Terri |
lol tell me about it, ive just finished rewatching season 2, next ill have to rewatch the seasons but with the commentary on lol | |
| DSi |
Lol I'd rewatch every season if I had them on DVD. | |
| Terri |
lol i have them all, ill be getting season 6 in october too  lol
|
|
| slade |
I'm almost certain that he wont return, there's no reasonable explanation. I doubt they pretended to kill him like Jack because for one, Henderson stabbed him they wouldn't have expected that and Jack was the only one with him when he died and he wasn't acting like he was still alive. | |
| DSi |
Yeah, you're right, I completely agree.
I don't see one reasonable explanation for Tony being alive. |
|
| Almeida |
Tony & Michelle are happily alive in the witness protection program & WILL NOT return in Season 7! | |
| DSi |
Right, right, and why again are they in the witness protection program? Who are they being protected from, and what did they witness? | |
| Almeida |
It's a fictional show, so why can't we write they are really alive - lol. Because they were targeted for death for some reason that doesn't make sense. I'm their case manager *rolls eyes* - I need to get another drink. | |
| DSi |
Lol, well you're right, it is a fictional show, and as much as I would love to see Tony and Michelle alive again, along with David Palmer, Edgar Stiles, George Mason, Teri Bauer, Curtis Manning, and countless other deceased characters, it is just illogical for them to be alive. But if the writers of 24 can come up with a convincing reason for their being alive, I'm all for it 
|
|
| Almeida |
I don't want Tony nor Michelle back. | |
| slade |
I wish they didn't kill Curtis...
Down here in Australia they're airing Season 6 again and i just watched the 4th episode again last night. Curtis was great in that episode, especially his last words, the way he said it was awesome and emotional... I wouldn't mind if Tony and Michelle came back or stayed dead
|
|
| Almeida |
I wasn't a Curtis fan, but I did not like how they portrayed him in Season 6. Nor having Jack kill him. Curtis deserved better. | |
| cindy |
I believe that the producers should bring back tony for season 7. It is plausible | |
| Almeida |
But .... DOES Carlos wish to return? | |
| DSi |
I don't know, but I hope he does because then maybe he will be in season 7
|
|
| Penny |
Carlos probably would return because he hasn't had much work since 24! All they had to do when Tony died to stop all these 'Tony theories' was to give him the silent clock. Why didn't they just give him the silent clock?!! Tony is my all time favourite character, and I was so angry that they killed him off like that - he needed a great exit. I heard the rumors of a return at the end of season 6 from him, and while having Tony back would be great, it also would be a bit of a cop out. Also, I heard a rumor that they were going to bring Tony back as a bad guy and say he was working with Henderson and that's why he wasn't dead. Nooooo! They can't bring Tony back as a baddie. That is just silly! | |
| DSi |
I don't think Tony would ever come back as a bad guy. He's too much of a great characters, besides, according to Jack in S4, he's the only person Jack can trust
And I agree I was very angry when he didn't get the silent clock. He deserves at least that level of respect. |
|
| DSi |
SPOILER WARNING!!!!!
|
|
| Josephine Marcus |
I guess he never got the silent clock because he never actually died. Who else never got a silent clock? Maybe they're not dead either!
As for Tony being a bad guy, I think that is pure 24. Insane plot twists that you just did not see coming. |
|
| cp123 |
um michelle is dead (u dont survive explosions of cars while ur in them, ever)
david is dead curtis is dead its plausible that tony is alive, i mean they faked jacks death with a serum, who's to say its not the same serum, that he's well and alive, and angry? |
|
| Josephine Marcus |
Yeah, I guess you're right. But I guess we'll just have to wait and see. | |
| cp123 |
after season 5, i trust them
after season 6, i begin to doubt my trust but its still there so let's see what story the writers can spoon feed us lol
|
|
| Josephine Marcus |
Yeah, season 6 wasn't quite as good as five, but it is still 100 times better than a lot of what's on TV today. |